Kelly’s journey into character education was initiated by an all-too-familiar student question: When are we ever going to use this? By no fault of their own, students enter first-year math courses viewing math as a utilitarian set of skills, helpful only insofar as they see them directly applying to their chosen career path. Some students question why a math course is even included on their degree plan in the first place. And that’s a good question: Why is math included on every degree plan regardless of the potential career path?
For Kelly, answering this question began by examining what she hopes students gain from taking her courses. Content is important, but equally important is the motivation and mindset behind acquiring it. Her focus became less about imparting math-specific knowledge and skills, which are likely to fade after time, and more about cultivating dispositions that could outlast the content itself: a capacity to think carefully, to persist when things get hard, to ask good questions (even when asking feels risky), and to wonder why rather than just how.
In her investigation on how character education could be incorporated into her discipline, Kelly explores three virtues – curiosity, courage, and perseverance – and the pedagogical practices she employs to make them explicit, transparent, and central to her course design. An example of application is below, where Kelly offers an activity designed to build the virtue of curiosity in her students:
Question-Storming: A Thinking Routine to Build Curiosity
This activity came about after exploring the Thinking Routines from Project Zero. After trying the “What do you notice? What do you Wonder?” in MATH 1332 (Contemporary Math), I wanted to tailor the experience to fit an algebra-based course.
Question-storming is as simple as introducing a new topic or a challenging problem and having students get into groups and brainstorm as many questions as they can think of about the topic or problem. Then the group selects one question to bring to the whole class. Repeatedly doing this throughout the semester normalizes both having questions and asking them. It’s common for students to think if they don’t immediately “get it” they aren’t smart enough or they can’t do it. Often, they just haven’t asked the right questions!
Students are used to answering questions in math classes, but they often have very little practice with asking questions about what they are learning. Training our brains to formulate good questions helps us make connections between topics and build curiosity while learning math more deeply.
Students need ample opportunities to practice question formation. This practice cannot be a one-off activity. The hope is that asking questions and wondering why will become instinctual.
For Dania Dwyer, first-year composition holds a distinctive place in general education because it is one of the few courses that nearly all students take, regardless of major, career goal, or level of confidence as writers. Composition introduces students not only to academic reading, research, and writing, but also to the habits of mind that sustain learning across fields and beyond college. Whether students go on to nursing, business, engineering, teaching, computer science, social work, or the arts, they will need to ask questions, analyze information, interpret language carefully, weigh evidence, revise their judgments, and communicate responsibly with others. Not only are these academic practices, they are also expressions of intellectual character.
Dania’s first-year composition courses already practice a form of character education. When students evaluate sources, respond to feedback, collaborate, reconsider assumptions, use or critique AI, or write for real audiences, they develop habits like curiosity, intellectual humility, attentiveness, empathy, and perseverance. Dania’s aim is not to bolt virtues onto an unchanged course but to make this embedded formation more visible, intentional, and just. Her composition courses also support the idea of a “good life,” one grounded not only in technical skill or career preparation but one that helps students listen well, reason carefully, respond thoughtfully, stay open to learning, and act with integrity. At its best, writing is not merely producing papers but a disciplined way of inquiring, judging, revising, and entering responsibly into a world one shares with others.
Dania examines character in the composition classroom through several practices: student-generated classroom values, collaborative research modules in Composition I that emphasize primary-source questions and critical AI use, Socratic questioning with an AI conversational tool, peer review, recurring reflections, and real-world applications of literary and textual analysis in Composition II. Through these practices, students repeatedly exercise curiosity, humility, attentiveness, empathy, and perseverance. Equally important, Dania argues, is the instructor’s pedagogical postures: teaching as a co-inquirer rather than the sole authority, modeling fallibility by sharing drafts, missteps, and research processes (including how she uses and critiques AI), and staying attentive to students’ diverse backgrounds and prior experiences with writing and schooling. Below is an example of an assignment from her course:
Critical AI examination assignments: These assignments ask students to use AI as an object of scrutiny rather than as a substitute for thought. For example, students might compare an AI-generated summary of a source with the source itself, identify distortions or omissions, and reflect on what responsible AI use requires in academic writing. This activity is especially well suited to composition because it joins source evaluation, rhetorical analysis, and ethical reflection (“Writing and AI in College Education”).
AI Socratic Question Assignment: Dania’s AI Socratic question assignment prompts students to make a claim about a primary text to start the conversation with the AI that Dania has intentionally set up to act not as an educator but rather an interlocutor with the students, asking more probing questions so student dig deeper into the primary source for evidence in sustaining, illuminating, or changing their claim altogether —essentially using AI to test their judgment rather than replace it. Students respond to sustained questioning (up to 10 times), support their claims with textual evidence, and reconsider answers that prove incomplete.
In using Blackboard’s AI Conversation tool in Socratic mode before major drafts, students get structured practice in intellectual humility, courage, and perseverance. Brief follow-up reflections ask them to identify when they acknowledged a limitation, revised a claim, or persisted through uncertainty. This assignment helps students understand that tools can be useful without being authoritative (“Introducing the new Blackboard AI Conversation Tool”; “Writing and AI in College Education”).